GiftSleuth

GiftSleuth is a forum where book lovers can help each other find perfect gifts for everyone on their lists. It's easy to use:

1. Post your gift dilemma. (You will need a nickname.) For example:

  • "I am searching for the perfect book for my mother. She was born in 1940 and loves cooking, crafts, and home decorating"
  • "I need to find a gift for a co-worker; I've seen him reading Orwell and Asimov in the lunch room so he must like Sci-Fi!"
  • The more information you can provide about the receiver, the better suggestions you will get.

    *TIP: Be sure to make your topic heading descriptive: include the receiver, your budget, and any other relevant details. (E.g. "Need gift for Mother, enjoys cooking, budget ~ $100.")

    2. Come back often to see the suggestions! (You can also "Subscribe" to a topic - view the FAQ section (at right) to learn more.)

    Finished your shopping? Visit often to give suggestions to others searching for the perfect gift.

    -

    Back To Discussion List

     GiftSleuth -  the civil war of the U.S. A novelnotify me whenever anyone posts in this discussionSubscribe  
     
    From: chory  Sep-26 9:18 am 
    To: ALL  (1 of 5) 
     206.1 

    Please help me find the best civil war novel for my neice, who is a civil war lover.  I know she has read many, many books, but perhaps

    someone out there could offer an idea.  Maybe someone has a favorite

    which might not be as well known as those which are regularly touted.

    Thanks!

     
       Options Reply 
      

     
    From: ml  Oct-1 7:31 pm 
    To: chory unread  (2 of 5) 
     206.2 in reply to 206.1 

    I can't think of any novel other than Gone With the Wind at the moment, but does it have to be a novel?
    If you niece doesn't have Mary Chestnut's Civil War,  or The Private Mary Chestnut, she might like them.  http://tinyurl.com/y8j6nu9
    There are a lot of other Civil War journals, letters and diaries which I think make fascinating reading. 
    An abe search with diary, journal or letters in the title field, and civil war in the keywords field, will get lots of hits.
    Is she interested in battles, strategy, etc, or in people? 
    I've read some Civil War books, including Mary Chestnut and Washington during the civil war, but it's not a specialty of mine.
    I do know though, that for the periods of history I'm interested in, I want to read non-fiction, and would be most disappointed if someone gave me a novel.
    She'd probably welcome a gift certificate for books, too.

     
       Options Reply 
      

     
    From: pembe  Oct-15 1:42 am 
    To: chory unread  (3 of 5) 
     206.3 in reply to 206.1 

    A little off the beaten track, I believe: a couple of civil-war period books by Frances Parkinson Keyes, rather dated now but still good reading, let me think, Madame Castel's Lodger, a fictionalised version of the life of Beauregard; and The Chess Players, which includes a lot of to-ing and fro-ing in Paris by Lafayette. Both books were very thoroughly researched.

    And one I hugely enjoyed just a few years ago, Shaman by Noah Gordon, about a British doctor who ends up living among the Indians in ?Illinois, and who, with his son, also a doctor, observes and doctors during the Civil War.

    And let's not forget that Little Women by Louisa May Alcott was set during the Civil War! How old is your niece?

    Pembe

     
       Options Reply 
      

     
    From: kikbut2  Oct-21 12:52 pm 
    To: chory unread  (4 of 5) 
     206.4 in reply to 206.1 
    The Killer Angels by Michael Shaara. It won a Pulizter Prize. It is about Gettysburg and is one of the best civil war novels ever writte


    STEVEN TEMPLE BOOKS (ABAC/ILAB)

    Literary First Editions
    Fine and Rare Books
    489 Queen St. West
    Toronto, ON M5V 2B4
    CANADA

    www.steventemplebooks.com

     
       Options Reply 
      

     
    From: SteveHL  Nov-4 5:14 pm 
    To: chory unread  (5 of 5) 
     206.5 in reply to 206.1 
    Another Pulitzer Prize winner, Andersonville by MacKinlay Kantor.  One of my favorite books of any kind.
     
       Options Reply 
      

    Rate My Interest:
       
    Adjust text size:
    Is this too complicated? Switch to Basic View

    Back To Discussion List